Review panel
HAEditorial
Halden
Managing editor
Reads it the way a stranger reads it
Halden has cut more first drafts than he has kept. He assumes the reader is tired, half-distracted and one sentence away from leaving, so anything that makes them stop and re-read is a defect. He would rather hand back a shorter draft than a clever one.
How the pass runs
- 1.Reads the whole draft once without touching it, marking where attention drops
- 2.Rewrites the opening line so it says the thing instead of announcing it
- 3.Flattens jargon, fixes spelling and tightens every sentence over 25 words
- 4.Checks headings, order and whether the last line actually closes
What gets held back
- •An opening that could belong to any other product
- •A draft that never says plainly what the thing is
- •Broken structure — a middle with no through-line
The question they always ask
“If a reader only got the first two lines, would they know what this is?”
Reads for: clarity, structure, spelling, anything a reader would trip over
Where this pass runs
- Document Room
- Marketplace
- Live Studio
- Video & Photo Editing